Information

Fire Accountability Board Meeting 12th August 2026 – Minutes

1  Welcome and introductions.

 

Attendees:

PFCC Danielle Stone (DS)

DPFCC Marianne Kimani (MK)

Nikki Watson (NW)

Vaughan Ashcroft (VA)

Paul Fell (PF)

ACFO Phil Pells (PP)

Nick Alexander (NA)

Leanne Hanson (LH)

Stuart McCartney (SMc)

ACO Paul Bullen (PB)

 

2                    Minutes and decisions of previous meeting

The Commissioner welcomed everyone to the meeting and the minutes of the previous meeting were approved.

 

ACFO Pells updated the meeting on the work being undertaken relating to response times that were beyond the SOR target and how the Service now had better data. The Commissioner felt this information would be useful for road safety meetings the OPFCC Performance Director updated the meeting on the development of the new partnership road safety strategy.

 

3 PART 1
   

Update on ECR Modelling Work

ACFO Pells provided an update on the modelling work and the opportunity to examine areas of business across the organisation. He noted the level of detail within the work was useful and was helping to inform the workshops being held to share the data and to start conversations which were being well received.

 

The meetings were also helping to address several issues relating to appliances and resources. He then explained the final report will be available soon due to the large amount of data that has been captured.

 

The Commissioner asked if the data had uncovered anything the Service was unaware of. ACFO Pells explained that it had and it was helping the Service to run future scenarios and modelling themselves. He also noted that more targeted recruitment was being undertaken. He then explained the challenge of interpreting so much data, but workshops were being run to examine and discuss possible future scenarios and options.

 

Following the end of the modelling work, ACFO Pells explained preparation for consultation would begin. The Commissioner noted that as a growing county, there was a need to look at the risks associated with the growth. ACFO Pells responded and explained that was part of the modelling and the feedback from the workshops had been useful in helping to develop options to inform the consultation.  The Chief Fire Officer added that as this work develops, the Service could pilot some of the possible recommendations whilst the consultation is underway.

 

The Commissioner enquired about the success of the previous consultation. The Chief Fire Officer noted that the previous consultation was for the CRMP and that had been successful with much higher levels of participation. The OPFCC Performance Director asked if there was a definitive list of items of business that the Fire and Rescue Service must consult on. The Chief Fire Officer responded and explained that consultation applied to anything that impacts on Service delivery. The OPFCC Performance Director felt it was important to be clear on this issue going forward.

 

In summary it was reported that the modelling work data that had been provided and was anticipated would be provided in the coming weeks was useful in assisting in making evidenced based decisions and allowing the proper and effective application of professional judgement in relation to them. Internal consultation and workshops were already taking place and where required external public consultation would take place on a potential range of options for a new target operating model. It was agreed that these options would need to be presented to the Commissioner during October before this took place.

 

Assurance Statement

The Commissioner was grateful for this update and assured that the additional modelling work that been commissioned was useful to make better informed and evidence-based decisions. She stressed the need for this to be done properly but at some pace, given the time that this had already taken to reach this point. The Commissioner looked forward to receiving options in October this year. She stated that she was pleased that this work was being done with the workforce and stressed the need for potential options to be presented to her ahead of any public consultation.

 

4 PART 2
   

Health and Safety

 

The Chief Asset Officer provided an update to the meeting and explained that this update had also been through the Service’s SLT meeting. She noted the low numbers of accidents but there had been spike of accidents during Q1 when the Service had to deal with many incidents which has impacted on the figures, however the Health and Safety Committee were examining the data. Overall accidents were lower than the previous year.

 

The Commissioner asked how the figures compared to other Services. The Chief Asset Officer explained that there was not much comparative data available but when compared to the force, the figures were lower. The Chief Asset Officer then explained how dangerous occurrences were defined and new practices being introduced into the Service. She then explained that traffic collisions involving Fire and Rescue vehicles were being addressed through further training and protocols. She explained the Service focus on different injuries and currently they were looking at low speed, non-blue light accidents.

 

ACFO Pells noted this was a national issue, but work was being undertaken to address it. The Commissioner asked if the Service monitor who is injured. The Chief Asset Office explained that the Service examine all the data to see if any trends appear so targeted work can be undertaken. In relation to the vehicles, she explained that lots of data was now available to help understand the wider picture more accurately. She explained the Service’s new Health and Safety manager was now in post and was encouraging the reporting of near misses to help inform the approach of the Service going forward.

 

The Commissioner asked about the frequency of fire stations being inspected. The Chief Audit Office explained that station audits are on a regular cycle and that different aspects of the stations are looked at different times and any issues are raised through the system. The Chief Fire Officer added that the Health and Safety Executive were planning to examine fire stations possibly in 2027. The Commissioner noted the Service lost 333 days to accidents and asked how this compared to other areas. The Chief Asset Officer noted this figure was a reduction, and work was being undertaken in relation to absence management and the difficulties in integrating the data with shift patterns. She explained that this data was in relation to all days rather than just working days so the real number lost of actual days at work was significantly less than this.

 

She explained that manual lifting and carrying were still issues for the Service, but work was ongoing to help address it. ACFO Pells noted that the new Health and Safety system and governance meant the Service was now better equipped to deliver reductions.

 

 

Assurance Statement

The Commissioner noted that it was her view that there were strong governance processes in place in relation to Health and Safety in the service. Which she recognised and was assured by. She felt that the service had good understanding of the issues that were causal factors in accidents and near misses and responded well to this, as she would expect in an organisation such as this. She was also pleased that the report and subsequent decision articulated that the service was able to learn from accidents and near misses with a view to enhancing the safety of the workplace and staff.

 

HMICFRS Round 4 Inspection

The Chief Fire Officer noted that the briefing had been postponed and that the meeting with HMICFRS would take place later in the day.

 

 

5 AOB

No further business was raised.